IN THE COURT OF
APPEAL MALAYSIA
(APPELLATE
JURISDICTION)
CIVIL APPEAL NO.:
Q-01-164-2011
BETWEEN
1. SUPERINTENDENT
OF LANDS AND
SURVEYS, KOTA
SAMARAHAN DIVISION
2. GOVERNMENT OF
THE STATE OF
SARAWAK ...
APPELLANTS
AND
1. LUKING ANAK
UDING
2. SIMAH ANAK
EMPALING
3. NYAMBAR ANAK
SUWAT ... RESPONDENTS
AND
TH PELITA SADONG
SDN BHD ... 1ST INTERVENER
RHB ISLAMIC BANK
BERHAD ... 2ND INTERVENER
HEARD TOGETHER
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO.:
Q-01-166-2011
BETWEEN
LEMBAGA
PEMBANGUNAN DAN
LINDUNGAN TANAH
Tingkat 10, Wisma
Bapa Malaysia
Petra Jaya,
Kuching
Sarawak ...
APPELLANTS
AND
1. LUKING ANAK
UDING
2. SIMAH ANAK
EMPALING
3. NYAMBAR ANAK
SUWAT ... RESPONDENTS
AND
TH PELITA SADONG
SDN BHD (Co. No. 67467)
(formerly known as
DD Pelita Sadong Plantation Sdn Bhd)
15th Floor Lot
15.01
Somerset Gateway
Building
No. 9 Jalan Bukit
Mata
93100 Kuching,
Sarawak ... INTERVENER
HEARD TOGETHER
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO.:
Q-02-756-2011
BETWEEN
NIRWANA MUHIBBAH
SDN BHD
Lot 298, 2nd
Floor, Lorong 9
Jalan Rubber
93400 Kuching
Sarawak ...
APPELLANT
AND
1. LUKING ANAK
UDING
2. SIMAH ANAK
EMPALING
3. NYAMBAR ANAK
SUWAT ... RESPONDENTS
[In the matter of
Suit No. 22-43-2002-I in the High Court at Kuching
Between
1. Luking anak
Uding
2. Simah anak
Empaling
3. Nyambar anak
Suwat ... Plaintiffs
And
1. Superintendent
of Lands and Surveys,
Kota Samarahan
Division ... 1st Defendant
2. Government of
The State of Sarawak ... 2nd Defendant
3. Lembaga
Pembangunan Dan Lindungan Tanah ... 3rd Defendant
4. Nirwana
Muhibbah Sdn Bhd (Co. No. 238058-H) ... 4th Defendant
HEARD TOGETHER
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO.:
Q-01-137-03/2012
BETWEEN
1. LEMBAGA
PEMBANGUNAN DAN LINDUNGAN
TANAH (LAND
CUSTODY AND DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY)
2. NIRWANA
MUHIBBAH SDN. BHD (238058-H)... APPELLANTS
AND
1. TR NYUTAN AK
JAMI (BICK. 544160)
2. GANGAK ANAK
GUMA (BICK. 500444)
3. LANGA ANAK KAMA
(BICK. 544351)
(Suing for and on
behalf of themselves and
183 other
residents of Kampung Lebor,
Jalan Gedong,
94700 Serian) ... RESPONDENTS
AND
1. TH PELITA
SADONG SDN BHD ... 1ST INTERVENER
2. TH PELITA
GEDONG SDN BHD ... 2ND INTERVENER
3. RHB ISLAMIC
BANK BERHAD ... 3RD INTERVENER
HEARD TOGETHER
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO.:
Q-01-136-03/2012
BETWEEN
THE STATE
GOVERNMENT OF SARAWAK ... APPELLANT
AND
1. TR NYUTAN AK
JAMI (BICK. 544160)
2. GANGAK ANAK
GUMA (BICK. 500444)
3. LANGA ANAK KAMA
(BICK. 544351)
(Suing for and on
behalf of themselves and
183 other
residents of Kampung Lebor,
Jalan Gedong,
94700 Serian) ... RESPONDENTS
[In the matter of
Suit No. 22-249-98-III(I) in the High Court in Sabah and Sarawak
at Kuching
Between
1. TR Nyutan AK
Jami (BIC.K. 544160)
2. Gangak Anak
Guma (BIC.K.500444)
3. Langa Anak Kama
(BIC.K.544351) ... Plaintiffs
(Suing for and on
behalf of themselves and
183 other residents
of Kampung Lebor
Jalan Gedong,
94700 Serian)
And
1. Lembaga
Pembangunan Dan Lindungan Tanah
(Land Custody and
Development Authority)
2. Nirwana
Muhibbah Sdn Bhd (Co. No. 238058-H)
3. Government of
The State of Sarawak ... Defendants]
CORAM:
RAMLY BIN HJ ALI,
JCA
ABDUL AZIZ BIN
ABDUL RAHIM, JCA
MOHD ZAWAWI BIN
SALLEH, JCA
(Date of decision:
19 August 2014)